Clay-shoveler’s fracture has been reported under different names in the literature in the early twentieth century in English trenchers, French soil workers, and German retired workers
7. Clay-shoveler’s fracture is very rare and C7 and T1 vertebrae are frequently affected. The spinous processes of these vertebrae are thinner and longer than the other vertebrae at close levels. Therefore, the risk of developing fractures is higher due to repetitive stress and strong trauma
7. Excessive hyperflexion-hyperextension or sudden forceful contractions of the trapezius and rhomboid minor muscle groups in trauma cause fractures
7,8. In our case, there was a hyperflexion mechanism of the head during the traffic accident. The pain is usually sharp, radiating from the midline bilaterally to the shoulders and arms. Patients typically tend to keep the neck slightly bent and the shoulders elevated. Neck and shoulder movements are painful. Neurological deficits may be seen due to accompanying pathologies
9. A neurological examination of our case was normal and she typically had severe pain. No concomitant traumatic pathology was observed. However, incidentally, atlantooccipital assimilation was observed. Although direct radiography is mostly sufficient in the diagnosis, it is necessary to apply CT and MRI to diagnose more serious additional spine and soft tissue injuries. In addition, direct radiographs may give an inadequate image, as patients tend to keep their shoulders up
10. MRI is particularly useful in demonstrating ligament damage. Anterior longitudinal ligament and anterior annulus fibrosus injuries can also be seen after hyperflexion-hyperextension injuries (2). In our case, there was a spinous process fracture at C3-C5-C6-T1-T2-T3-T4 levels on CT images. There was no additional bone pathology except atlantooccipital fusion. We did not detect ligament damage or any other pathology on MRI images.
The atlantooccipital joint is between the superior articular facet of the atlas and the occipital condyles. Although they are two separate joints, they move together. It is primarily responsible for movement in the sagittal plane. Flexion is limited by the dens axis corresponding to the anterior margin of the foramen magnum, and extension by tectorial membrane tension. The alar ligaments restrict the lateral and rotational movements of this junction to about 5 degrees.
Neurological disorders often occur in the 3rd and 4th decades of life in the patient with atlantooccipital assimilation. Symptoms such as ataxia, numbness, and pain may occur by compression of the spinal cord due to soft tissue and bone structure abnormalities11. However, we did not see spinal cord compression in our case and she did not have any symptoms. In addition, rheumatology consultation was requested in our case and rheumatological disease was not considered.
We mentioned that hyperflexion injuries are involved in the etiology of such cases. Since there was also atlantooccipital assimilation in our case, we thought that movement was restricted at the craniovertebral junction due to hyperflexion injury and the tension force was concentrated in the posterior spine. Therefore, we concluded that multiple-level spinous process fractures occur and especially affect upper cervical levels. When we analyzed the literature, we did not find a similar case.
In conclusion, multiple levels spinous process fractures are extremely rare lesions that occur as a result of direct trauma or repetitive traction. They are usually conservative without the need for surgery. However, as in our case, a more detailed neuroradiological examination should be performed to detect accompanying incidental anomalies or more serious spinal traumas.
Availability of data and materials:
Data and material are available on a reasonable request from the author.
Abbreviations:
CT: Computed tomography
MRI: Magnetic resonance imaging
NSAID: Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug
VAS: Visual analog scale
Funding: Nil.
Contributions: All authors contributed equally.
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate: Approval has been taken from the ethics committee.
Consent for publication: The patient's consent was obtained for publication.
Competing interests: The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Acknowledgements: Not applicable.
)
)